Marine Chronometer model · external validation · 11 October 2026 · with it: would a chronometer made to the model run?

Does the model behave like a real Hamilton Model 21?

The model already agreed with itself and with the 1948 manual's adjustment figures: that is parity, not proof. Here it is compared with recordings of real, running Model 21s it was never fitted to, by two independent tests: the sound (the timing of the clicks inside each beat) and the picture (the balance's swing read frame by frame).

Escapement timing
Confirmed
The tooth strikes the impulse jewel 7–9 ms after the unlocking, as the corrected model has it. The old model's 2 ms is ruled out.
Real swings
≈205° · ≈300–320°
Two movements, by sound (on the model of 14 October 2026; 212° and 295° on the model of 11 October). The manual asks for 247.5–270°; the model runs at 255°.
Sound vs picture
Agree, sound high
Within their uncertainties; the sound reads about 15° above the video's likeliest reading.
Balance's run-down
TF ≥ 120–160 s
A real start builds up far more slowly than the model's 67 s allows (52 s until 12 October 2026, when the endstone's friction was measured and the mainspring became the videos'; 68 s until 14 October 2026). Not the escape wheel's chase: with any shape of the escapement's work the start wants 104 s or more. Recorded as an open question.

What is tested

A detent escapement makes its sounds once per oscillation of the balance (every 0.5 s). On the active swing: the discharge jewel meets the passing spring and lifts the detent (unlocking), the wheel is released, the detent lands back on its stop, the escape wheel's tooth strikes the impulse jewel, and the next tooth locks on the stone. Half a period later, on the return swing, the jewel meets the trip (gold) spring and the spring comes clear.

The times between these clicks depend on the balance's swing (a larger swing crosses the escapement's angles faster) and on how the escape wheel moves once released. That is exactly what release 2.21.00 changed: the old model treated the wheel as a gear that lands on the jewel at once; the corrected one lets it start from rest and chase the jewel. The two make different predictions:

At a swing of 255°Corrected model (dynamics.js)Old model (39d6919)
Unlocking → strike7.2 ms2.1 ms
Strike → lock8.5 ms12.9 ms
Their ratio (does not depend on the swing)≈ 0.85 (0.77–0.89 over 190–330°)0.16

Both intervals shrink as the swing grows, so one interval alone reads as a swing. Their ratio doesn't, so hearing all three clicks tells the models apart at any swing.

The recordings

YouTube videos of real Model 21s, catalogued in References/VIDEOS.md. They are other people's work, cited and never copied into the repository: each is linked at the moment used. A local copy of this report, built outside the repository (build_report.py --local), also carries short audio excerpts and the video frames.

VideoWhat it isListenUsed for
s7VW3RiJ97E
RM Watch & Clock, 30 s, 1080p
The escapement running, close; the cleanest sound listen from 0:05 Sound: the best test of the models
We1dLNXiBj0
bunnspecial, Part 1 of 3, 3 min, 720p
Balance visible through the plate's cutouts; at rest, then started by hand at 0:55; speech over it the start, 0:52 · running, 2:20 Sound and video: the cross-check
xDKFZaY88cM
James Martin, 3 min, 1080p
A unit running in an echoing room; the video is edited listen from 0:10 Sound: rough
XJQCgMV_GA8
Deafboy, 75 s
Keyhole view of the locking stone; sound only in the first 13 s listen from 0:01 Sound: inconclusive
FpolZSipVmQ
pefkipefki, 68 s
Rollers seen from above, hand-held listen from 0:10 Sound: inconclusive

Test 1: the sound (tools/acoustic.py)

Each recording's beats are averaged (each placed on the running average by cross-correlation; beats with speech or handling are rejected by their quiet floor), the clicks' onsets are found on the 4–12 kHz envelope in decibels (the case rings near 1 kHz, so lower bands blur), each with its spread over 200 bootstrap resamples of the beats. The model's events are then paired one to one with the onsets, the swing the only free parameter (then the beat error too), for both models.

s7VW3RiJ97E: the cleanest recording corrected model fits; old model can't

Average beat of s7VW3RiJ97E with onsets and both models' best fits
Left: the active swing, right: the return swing half a period later. Orange 4–12 kHz, blue 1.5–4 kHz, in dB over the beat's quiet floor. Black lines: onsets found; green solid: the corrected model at its best swing; red dashed: the old model at its best. Numbers on the lines: 4 unlocking, 2 release, 3 detent lands, 0 strike, 1 lock, 8 the jewel meets the trip spring, 9 it comes clear.

The other recordings

Average beat of We1dLNXiBj0 from 2:08
We1dLNXiBj0 from 2:08 (running, 93 beats). Two loud clicks 6.36 ms apart, read as the strike and the lock: 299°; the return swing's own clicks, 5.88 ms apart, 324° (306° at one sigma); all four fitted at once 316°.
Average beat of xDKFZaY88cM
xDKFZaY88cM: the room rings for 100 ms and hides the clicks after the loudest. Corrected model about 180° in beat, 209° with 3° beat error: rough, and the video is edited so its sound may be too.
Average beat of XJQCgMV_GA8
XJQCgMV_GA8: only 24 beats (13 s of sound), several weak onsets on the loudest click's flank; corrected (269°) and old (259°) fit about equally. Inconclusive.
Average beat of FpolZSipVmQ
FpolZSipVmQ: the loudest click is spread over 8 ms and no clear click is heard on the return swing; every fit pairs only two or three clicks. Inconclusive.

A real start: the best test (We1dLNXiBj0)

In We1dLNXiBj0 the balance stands still until 0:52, a stick turns it about 65° and lets go at 0:55.2, and the escapement builds the swing up over the next minutes. The video measures that swing; the sound, read in 6-second stretches, shows the clicks moving as it grows. This turns one recording into a whole range of swings.

Average beats in successive 6-second stretches, the unlocking and lock closing in on the strike
Each trace is the average of about 11 beats. The loudest click (the strike) is at 0. The unlocking (about −9 ms) and the lock (from +12 ms at 1:05 to +5 ms at 2:05) close in as the swing grows. After about 2:05 the lock falls under the detection threshold; the unlocking stays.

Strike → lock against the swing the video measures

Data table

From 1:23 to 2:05 the corrected model pairs the three clicks as unlocking, strike and lock with only the swing free, χ² ≈ 0 in all nine stretches, and the old model fits worse in every one. The measured points fall along the corrected curve's shape (and nowhere near the old one), but sit 6–14 % below it at the video's swing: equivalently, the sound reads a swing 15–30° above the video's from 1:20 on (the horizontal bars span the video's possible readings).

The swing through the start: video, sound, and the model

Data table

The video's swing (blue line; shaded: its possible readings, a screw hole apart) rises from 66° to 244–267° at 2:03 and is still rising about 1°/s. The sound's swing (orange dots, read from the strike-to-lock interval on the current model) follows it within 2–11° from 1:23 to 1:59, and the steady stretch after 2:08 reads about 300–320°. The grey curves are the same start run in the model (tools/startup.js): with the model's balance run-down TF = 67 s the swing builds up too fast and flattens too early (11.5–12.2° rms from the video at its best drive; 14.5–16.7° at the 52 s it had until 12 October 2026); a run-down of 160 s or more, with the drive at 60–75 % of the model's torque, follows the video within 2.8–5.1° rms.

Is it the escape wheel's chase onto the impulse jewel? The clicks of each stretch, read on the video's swing rather than the model's timing (startup.js --chase), put the strike at the balance angle where the model's tooth lands up to about 217° of swing (within 0.4°); above it the real strike stops moving (about −6.5°) while the model's tooth lands later and later, 6.2° over 196–252°: its wheel, let go from rest, chases the jewel, so the model gives a small swing a little more of the escapement's work than a running one (1.34 times at 60° against 255°; moved as the clicks move, about 1.24). That is not why the start is slow: the averaged build-up law, refitted with the work falling as the model's, the clicks' or not at all, still wants TF 156–160, 136–142 or 104–106 s (each within 2° rms; 67 s misses by 5.7–10.1°), settling at 294–316°. No drive, inertia or give of the train's teeth makes the landing stop moving; what does is open.

Test 2: the swing on video (tools/swing.py)

At 30 frames a second a 0.5 s oscillation has only 15 frames, and in mid-swing the balance turns about 100° per frame and is a blur. Near each turning point it is almost still, so those frames are nearly sharp. The tool finds the turning points by mirror symmetry (frames equally before and after a turn look alike), reads the screws' angle there, and measures how far each extreme moves from one turning point to the same side's two periods later.

The frames it reads are not reproduced here (the video is other people's work): the balance at rest at 0:49, held by the stick and let go at 0:55.2, its turning points through to 2:01; swing.py draws them, with the screws' 5° ticks, into $MC_VIDEO/swing.

Measured swing against time with alias band, and growth rate per side
Left: the measured swing (black, the middle reading; grey band, the alternatives) with the averaged build-up law fitted (orange: settling at 292°, TF 102 s), the manual's band (green) and the model's 255° (blue line). Right: the growth rate from each side of the swing; the two sides agree, and a slip of one screw hole would show as a 15°/s spike.

A second movement recovering: xM_mxtGfeqQ slow, like the start

BunnSpecial's carrying-case video (a break-circuit Model 21) has the camera on a tripod about 45° above the running movement from 8:56 to 11:20, the balance's rim and screws seen through the train bridge's cutout. It was first read as a steady swing; it is not. The movement had been handled on its side (8:00–8:50) and set down flat at about 8:52, and the swing grows from 170° at 8:56 to 186 ± 2° at 9:12, 201° at 9:28, 216–224° at 9:58–10:12 and 226–229° at 10:19–10:43, both extremes moving outward about a fixed rest. The turn patterns give the swing modulo 90° (the same brass screw at the front at both turns); 96° and 366° are excluded by how the frames near a turn are blurred, and 276° by the sound (acoustic.py on 8 s stretches reads 195–212° at 9:00–9:24) and by how the click interval shortens as the swing grows (188 ± 14° at 9:12, needing no image scale). Period 0.50002 s over 214 periods. The frames are not reproduced here: 8:56, 9:57, 10:19. The scripts and plots are in $MC_VIDEO/oq/xm; the series is swing.json's xM_mxtGfeqQ.

Data table

It recovers as slowly as the start builds up. The averaged law alone (A² relaxing to its final value as exp(−2t/TF)) fits it with . Run in dynamics.js from its first reading (startup.js --xm), the model at its own TF of s misses it by 7.3° rms at its best drive, 80 %; the fit improves steadily with a slower run-down, 4.3° at 120 s, 2.5° at 200 s, 1.5° at 320 s (the grid's end), at 45–60 % of the drive. A second movement, a different kind of disturbance (a recovery from handling, not a start from rest) and a swing read to ±2–4° rather than a screw hole: it says the same as We1dLNXiBj0.

Do the two tests agree?

Data table

Yes, within their uncertainties. On the model as it stands (14 October 2026), through the start the sound's strike-to-lock reading follows the video within 2–11° (198–255° against 196–252° on its middle reading, 1:23–1:59), and the steady stretch, about 300–320° (299° strike to lock; the return swing's own clicks 306–324°), sits at and above the video's extrapolated 280–311°. On the model of 11 October the sound read 15–30° above the video, which looked like a strike-to-lock arc 6 % too long; the changes since (the detent's preload, the balance's run-down, the train's measured inertia) closed it. Is the loud click the strike? Taken as the detent coming home on its stop button instead, the first interval's trend fits better, but the lock comes 1.4–1.9 ms early, and the steady 255° that reading gives, the return swing's clicks (which involve neither) rule out: it is the strike.

Implications for the model

  1. The corrected escapement is right where it mattered. On real Model 21s the wheel catches the impulse jewel 7–9 ms after the unlocking, and the intervals follow the swing as dynamics.js computes them, through a whole start. The old kinematic wheel (strike 2 ms after the unlocking) is ruled out by the cleanest recording and by every stretch of the start.
  2. Real swings vary from unit to unit. About 205° on one movement, about 300–320° running on another (about 150–200° on a third, roughly). The manual's 247.5–270° and the model's 255° lie between: the model's swing is a reasonable middle, not a measured value for any one chronometer.
  3. Each movement has a beat error. The return swing's clicks fall a few milliseconds off where an in-beat balance puts them, differently in each recording: 5–12° out of beat when fitted. The model assumes a chronometer exactly in beat (the manual's adjustment); that is fine, but it means the sound can't test the trip spring's geometry or the shape of the discharge jewel's end (its back's radius).
  4. The balance loses its swing more slowly than the model says. A real start rises far more slowly than the model's 67 s run-down allows; the fit wants TF of at least about 120–160 s (Q ≈ 750–1,000) with about 60–80 % of the model's drive, and gives no upper bound. That is beyond the 65–113 s the balance's parts allow in physics.js with the endstone's friction measured (32–62 s before it was). A second movement says the same (12 October 2026): xM_mxtGfeqQ's swing, recovering after handling and read to ±2–4°, fits TF 133 ± 4 s by the averaged law and 200–320 s in dynamics.js (the model's 68 s then: 7.3° rms). Against that, published figures put chronometer balances at Q 300–700 (Rawlings, as quoted by Vardi 2014) and a "Hamilton chronometer" at about 220 (Bateman's chart in Vardi 2014): TF 35–110 s. It is recorded in OPEN-QUESTIONS.md; the model is not changed on one hand-started movement whose absolute swing is known only to a screw hole.
  5. The escape wheel reaches the jewel sooner than the model's at a running swing. The real strike stops moving with the swing from about 217°, the model's tooth lands later and later: a small difference in the escapement's work (1.24 against 1.34 times at 60°), not the cause of the slow start.

Gaps, and what would close them

GapWhy it mattersWhat would close it
No steady swing seen on video without aliasesThe video reading is known only to a 15° screw hole, which limits the sound–picture comparison to ~1.5 σ. xM_mxtGfeqQ picks its alias by the sound and the clicks' interval, but it is still recovering at 229°A Model 21 running steadily with one balance feature in view from above (a timing weight, an arm's end) for a minute, on a tripod; KLUwI2UUCMQ 47:03 and W9gy2gjvZHc are candidates, not yet measured
The balance's free run-down never measuredSets Q (the model's TF 67 s), the drive the train must give, and the build-up time; the start suggests ≥ 120–160 s, the second movement's recovery 133 s by the averaged law; none is in any downloaded video (searched again 12 October 2026)A video of the balance swinging freely with the train held by the blocking screw, its swing timed until it stops
One clean recording decides old vs corrected outrightElsewhere the unlocking is too quiet or the room too live to hear all three clicksMore close recordings with a still microphone, or a timegrapher (it hears the same clicks)
Which click is which, on a steady recordingTwo loud clicks 6.4 ms apart: their names come from the start, where all three are heard, and the return swing's clicks confirm themA start (as in We1dLNXiBj0) or a contact microphone with a slowed-down video of the escapement in sync
Beat error confounds the return swingHides any test of the trip spring and the shape of the jewel's endVideo of the escapement's return swing at high frame rate, or a unit put exactly in beat first
Different movements, different statesSwings range about 150–320°; mainspring, oil and adjustment are unknownA timegrapher reading (swing, beat error, rate) on a serviced unit, fully wound
Recording artefactsYouTube's Opus coding smears transients by up to ~1 ms (0.3 ms allowed per onset); the video in xDKFZaY88cM is editedOriginal, uncompressed recordings

Method, limits and files

Readings are cited by video ID and time. "Sure", "fairly sure", "rough" and "inconclusive" are stated per result in References/VIDEOS.md.